Posted by Clavers on (December 29, 2013, 13:46 GMT)
A few points about Sobers vis-a-vis Kallis:
Both had outstanding batting averages, Sobers a little higher, but of the two Sobers could probably score faster.
As a bowler, the glaring difference of course is that Sobers bowled left-arm spin, both orthodox and Chinaman, in addition to fast-medium. He also bowled a lot more overs than Kallis. Kallis averaged 12.4 overs per innings in which he bowled; Sobers 22.6. Sobers had the slower strike rate but better economy, and his test bowling average came out slightly higher than Kallis (34.03 to 32.53). So in a few respects he offered more to his captain than Kallis did.
While Kallis was a fine fieldsman, Sobers was among the very best ever. There are video clips on Youtube of Sobers taking catches at "silly leg slip." Ridiculously close to the batsman; freakish.
Sobers would be 2nd player picked after Bradman in an all-time World XI. But if Sobers were "injured," Kallis would replace him as the batting all-rounder.