Thread: Chinese experiment which 'edits' DNA of human embryos ignites ethical controversy

Originally Posted by nidhogg

Originally Posted by harrybarracuda

Is transplanting healthy genes to replace defective ones any different to transplanting organs?
.

Uh, actually yes, it is significantly and fundamentally different. The problem with this work is they are doing it at the level of the germ line - they affect DNA that is passed on (inherited) to offspring. You do not pass on the genetic effects of your kidney transplant to your (future) kids.

Very, very different to a transplant.

If you don't die of kidney or heart failure, you get to pass your genes on.

*Cough*