Shield:
Season 1, The
Apollo Score: Apollo Score: 92. Click for an explanation of the scoring system.
Rating 9.5 out of 10.
Shop for the Poster
Shield: Season 1, The
The opening credits of The Shield end with a shot of a broken up police badge pieced back together as if it were a mosaic. This is a perfect symbol for the show’s premise about a Los Angeles police precinct where good and evil mingle together in perfect disharmony. In the end, like the mosaic badge, the department comes together as one extremely dysfunctional family, reliant on one another no matter how reluctantly.
Los Angeles is a nasty place. At least that’s what seems to be stuffed down our throats in movies, television shows and news of various police trials and street riot tribulations. Midway through the show’s first episode it looks as though The Shield might end up being another consumable rogue cop drama. There’s the appearance of good cops and bad cops. The good cops go by the book in their attempts to stop crime. Sometimes it works, and sometimes it turns up a dead end. On the other hand, Detective Vic Mackey’s (Michael Chilkis) special operations strike force is made up of the department’s foulest. They take advantage of the badge, striking deals with drug dealers, turning a blind eye to girls turning tricks and snagging some of the evidence for their own benefit. Guess who gets the best results come payday?
New captain David Aceveda (Benito Martinez) is in a struggle to gain the confidence of his force. The cops see right through him to his dream of making city council. Aceveda knows that Vic and his boys are into trouble, but without evidence, there’s nothing he can do. The first episode sets the scene for what appears to be a season-long investigation into Vic’s exploits. All the signs are there because the rogue cop genre isn’t full of surprises, right? But by the end of the episode a couple of spins sends the show into new territory that continues throughout all 13 episodes. The writing makes it easy for you to guess what is going to happen at certain plot points. But like an investigation that breaks wide open with a single piece of new evidence, The Shield sends you reeling by constantly taking the route of the unthinkable. What makes it even better is that all the twists and changes of pace are logical.
Even with a large cast, there are no weak characters here. Vic is the centre of the ensemble. His early actions make you want to hate him, but then he goes and does something really good to partially balance it out. In his heart, Vic is a man out for what’s best for his fragile family. However, the extremes that he goes to are certainly questionable. Chilkis brings the balance of intensity and sensitivity required to establish a love-hate relationship between viewers and his character. Another standout is CCH Pounder who plays Detective Claudette Wyms, the wise and steely veteran who observes and leads through nudging. The role was originally written as a male character, but in casting Pounder, we get more variety and there are surprises added to the plot. At Pounder’s request, the dialogue wasn’t changed to something more feminine, further playing off our preconceived notions of what a cop story should be.
The refreshing lack of predictability and rejection of good and evil being two clearly definable entities make season one of The Shield unforgettable. And it’s a good thing that it’s on DVD too. Otherwise folks like myself who don’t have an infinite number of channels and premium cable access would be missing out in a big way.