The Thailand expat forum for Travel, Lifestyle and Fun.

guyinthailand

"NORWEGIAN police are reported to be keen to pursue the case of the two young tourists who died mysteriously on the holiday island of Phi Phi almost two months ago.

Officers in the home town of one of the victims, Julie Bergheim, are said to be agitating for a second autopsy in an attempt to solve the riddle of the Laleena Guesthouse."

Phi Phi Riddle: Pursuing the Deaths of Two Tourists - Phuket Wan

English Noodles

I guess so.

phunphin

i wondered if it could be methane from a backed up sewage system, given that alot of resorts use the concrete tube systems , not modern septic tanks.
if the underground tanks are not vented correctly or they get blocked, gas will backflow into your room.

Rural Surin

The symptoms manifested were of bacterial models, so one could rule out a short-term exposure to methane.

MustavaMond

" Bacterial models" ?

Sounds like someone has been watching too much Miami CSI
Symptoms could be viral or bacterial induced, but the fact that neither have been found, or at least the Phuket Ragette claims ( always take their reports with a grain of salt..) neither have been found by Thai authorities , and the lung tissue biopsy in US didn't either, I'm sticking with pesticide or other toxic agent - either administered accidentally or intentionally within the establishment's rooms .

Something the international press rarely reports is the, what- almost 4000 deaths in the south in four years from terrorist attacks.?
That's probably the highest rate in the world.

Are Muslim terrorists spreading from the south? Why not ? And attacking tourist destinations seems a more effective target than teachers and monks in the far south that nobody in the rest of the world gives a shit about .

Maybe Phi Phi was a practice run...

__________________



Profiteering From War and Disease, Corporate Owned "News" Media Deliberately Dis-Informs in Order to Further Its Own Agenda- PROFIT

guyinthailand

click here
Thailand tourist's lung tissue 'gone' after mysterious death - CNN.com

Thailand tourist's lung tissue 'gone' after mysterious death

• Story Highlights
• Seattle woman is one of 2 tourists who died of unknown causes
• Family says pathologist says her "lungs were 100 percent congested"
• Thai officials have been focusing on food poisoning as cause of death

updated 11:47 p.m. EDT, Fri May 29, 2009

Michael

if anyone is listening by now (which I doubt) I've heard this story before.

Tourists order mussells and oysters, which tend to come from Songkhla, ( where I live) and delicious they are too.

Transporting them to offshore Western islands by whatever means, in the back of a pick-up, plus the ferry journey, errrrm......

Some weeks ago when someone said they had a problem, I said "Didn't people warn you? Buying shellfish in Krabi province? Now you know."

Michael

Of course some restaurants will invest in refrigerated trucks and absolute hygiene throughout the logistics process.

tjyflhol

Has there been another murder threat?

guyinthailand

Phi Phi Deaths Riddle: 'It's Finished,' say Police

Friday, July 31, 2009
ALMOST three months on, whatever caused the deaths of two young tourists on the idyllic holiday island of Phi Phi remains a mystery.

Guests are back staying in Rooms Four and Five at Laleena, the unpretentious two-storey guesthouse that lies at the heart of the riddle.

Although the pair had never met, American Jill St Onge, 27, and Julie Bergheim, 22, fell ill in those adjoining rooms, and died suddenly, horribly, within hours of each other.

But why? Thirteen weeks on, nobody can say.

Although there has been speculation galore, official investigations have so far drawn a blank, and seem likely to continue to do so.

For grieving family and friends in America and Norway, hope of ever fully understanding what took place half a world away that weekend in early March seems to be gradually disappearing.

There is some understandable anger at the lack of answers.

Yet on the holiday island where Miss St Onge and Miss Bergheim died within hours of each other, life goes on.

At Laleena, owner Rat Chuped says seven of the 10 rooms are currently occupied . . . including Rooms Four and Five.

After the deaths, she even spent a night in one of the rooms herself, just to reinforce her confident belief that nothing in the rooms was the cause.

She still maintains that the guesthouse, owned with her husband since before the 2004 tsunami laid waste to the island, has no connection with the two deaths.

''I've called the police and an officer told me, 'Don't worry, everything is finished, it's over,'' she said to Phuketwan today.

''If that's the case, then I would like the parts from the air-conditioning unit returned, to save me from having to buy another one.''

Those air-conditioner parts and samples taken from household chemicals at Laleena may hold the last hope for an answer.

Researchers at a Thai university laboratory have yet to report whether the samples and the parts hold any clues to the mystery.

However, the potential clues were not taken until three weeks after the deaths, so the likelihood of a scientific revelation seems remote.

Today, Thai forensic officials in Bangkok rejected criticism that their report from the St Onge autopsy was inadequate, saying that it matched international standards.

An online blog, updated by St Onge's brother, says: ''The Thailand autopsy report is a joke. It was about three pages long and most of it was margin space and emblems.

''I believe here in the 'States an autopsy report starts at around 20 pages, and for something like what happened to Jill would be much longer.''

According to the blog, the autopsy ''did verify that there were NO drugs or alcohol in her system, so those bogus rogue Thailand reports from 'Government officials' can be put to rest.

''We are still waiting for some more reports to be translated from Thailand, and we have been in contact with Julie's family (the young lady that also died in the same guest house).''

The Thai autopsy reported low level of one particular enzyme, but that does not appear to hold great significance.

Although tissue samples were taken at the time of the Bangkok autopsy and tested in the US on behalf of the St Onge family, no conclusions on the cause of death have been established there or in Thailand.

St Onge's body was cremated and her ashes were carried home. It is believed Bergheim's body was transported to Norway, where police from her home town subsequently called for further investigations.

At one stage, Interpol's help was said to have been requested, but the international policing agency did not respond to email questions from Phuketwan.

American Ryan Kells, 31, who was travelling with Miss St Onge and also fell sick, then recovered, has consistently blamed the death of his bride-to-be on some kind of chemical.

There was a strange smell present in the room, he says, when they checked in that fateful Saturday, May 2.

The 19-year-old Norwegian woman travelling with Miss Bergheim, and already occupying the ground-floor room next door, has been less forthcoming.

She is yet to publicly reveal her views on what happened, although she too fell sick and only recovered after intensive care in two Thai hospitals.

The mysterious deaths remain just that. Tourists who have followed the two couples to the holiday island seem undeterred.

And on Phi Phi, where contented visitors provide the sole source of income, it's unlikely that locals will ever raise the deaths with strangers, or dwell on the mystery for long.

Phi Phi Deaths Riddle: 'It's Finished,' say Police - Phuket Wan

guyinthailand

from a blogspot about Jill St Onge click here: About Jill: Contact the Embassy...

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

Contact the Embassy...

"The lack of answers to the death of Jill and Julie is frustrating and disturbing at the same time. Please contact the embassy and let them know people are still following this tragedy. We would like some sort of action/answer/proof that something is being done to find out what happened.


"Email the US Embassy in Thailand at acsbkk[at]state.gov Let them know we are tired of not getting results!


"The contact there is Charles Carson. In the subject line put "Attn: Charles Carson in regards to the death of Jill St. Onge"

BugginOut

A German who died in Phuket in May:

Stay away from Phuket, for sure.

nidhogg

But lets be clear here that there is no way that cholera could be the cause of the death of the ladies on Phi Phi. Cholera is characterized by massive diarrhea, and that would hardly be left out of any report (from the boyfriend etc).

__________________
facilis est descensus Averni

guyinthailand

Phi Phi Deaths Riddle: Norway Chases Answers

Phi Phi Deaths Riddle: Norway Chases Answers - Phuket Wan

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

OFFICERS in Norway are trying to solve the mysterious deaths of two young women tourists on the holiday island of Phi Phi that have baffled Thai police.

The body of American Jill St Onge, 27, was cremated in Thailand soon after an autopsy in Bangkok. Forensic research on blood and tissue samples in the US and Thailand has since failed to find a cause of death.

After an autopsy in Thailand, the body of Julie Bergheim, 22, was transported back to Norway in June. Now a new series of examinations is to be conducted in Norway in an attempt to solve the riddle.

Both women, who occupied adjoining rooms at Laleena Guesthouse, died within hours of each other at the Phi Phi hospital on May 2 and May 3 from a mysterious malady.

Many theories have been put forward about what could have possibly killed the two young tourists and made their travelling companions ill.

But forensic scientists have so far drawn a blank.

Like Phuketwan reporter Chutima Sidasathian, Norwegian reporter Stig Martin Solberg travelled to Phi Phi after the deaths to cover the mystery.

Today he reports in nettavisen.no that Norwegian forensic police are determined to find the cause of the deaths.

''Norwegian police and the forensic institute in Oslo have not given up hope,'' he reports.

The new inquiries are being led by Sjaker Haaheim, of police-district Sondre Buskerud. This is the Norwegian county where Miss Bergheim lived.

''After the body of Miss Bergheim arrived in Norway in early June, the Rett Medical Institute in Oslo provided a full autopsy,'' he said.

Now, with the cooperation of Thai authorities and the Norwegian Embassy in Bangkok, a fresh investigation is being undertaken.

''We have received all relevant documents from the local police as well as the results of analysis by the forensic institute in Bangkok,'' he said.

''Now we aim to help the Bergheim family members to get as many answers about the cause of death as possible."

A preliminary report from the new autopsy has been done and investigators are waiting for the full report.

''When it comes is uncertain. It requires complicated analysis, so no date can be specified for completion.''

He warns against being too optimistic.

''It is by no means certain that we can solve the mystery, but we will do what we can.''

Consul Birgit Brantenberg at the Norwegian embassy in Bangkok told Solberg: ''The investigation under the auspices of the provincial police in Krabi is not completed.''

Laboratory tests on samples of chemicals and air-conditioning parts, taken from Laleena three weeks after the deaths, are continuing in Thailand.

It's business as usual back at the Laleena on Phi Phi, where guests now stay in the same rooms where Miss Berheim and Miss St Onge fell ill.

MustavaMond

I want to know more about the young Kuwait women in late July who died mysteriously in Phuket AFTER visiting Phi- Phi on a day trip. She was coughing
(so it is reported.)

And the German man in late June was vomiting. The "cholera "reference came from either uninformed or misinforming, hospital worker.

Diarhea isn't reported at all except the first Norwegian man in May and that HAS been explained as food poisoning, uh or has it? We aren't getting the whole story on anything else .

I've lost count, but I think it's up to 12- 13 unexplained deaths in the Phi -Phi/ Phuket region since June 1-not counting the handful of suspected violent homocides and washed up bodies.

I wish someone would run the numbers- Southern Thailand IS DANGEROUS for tourists AND Thais.

I'm finding the local press/internet news increasingly loathe to report on anything threatening tourism-today's PhuketWan BS headline;
"..The myth perpetuated by western press,.. T. Land is dangerous.."

Fabian

Cholera sounds like the news that will help tourism.

matchless51

When backpacking how many times have i gone straight for the 5 baht bottle of water by the 6 pack sitting out in the sun for god knows how long over the 14 baht bottle in the 4 degree C, cabinet, i would be checking the el cheapo local bottleing plant. sounds like contanimated water to me. either pathogens or some sort of toxic shock from the cheap plastic bottle.
So sorry to loose healthy kids.

Agent_Smith

Serial killer?

guyinthailand

http://teakdoor.com/thailand-and-asi...hi-deaths.html (Norway proffs go to work on PhiPhi deaths riddle)

The above post at least needs to be referenced here, as this thread is the most complete accounting.

MustavaMond

I'd really like to know why the St Onge family cremated Jill's body so quickly.. What kind of coroner would allow a body to be cremated under such circumstances - A Thai coroner ..

Did the US Embassy advise otherwise?

God- damn it, some shit went on in the Phi Phi /Phuket region last summer St Onge, Bergheim in Phi Phi , The German man in Phuket, the Kuwait woman who took a day trip to Phi Phi returned to Phuket and died... Assorted bodies washing up, stranglings , shootings, C'mon, has it always been this.... deathly ?

Tourist, Beware !


Text of article ref above ^ post


http://teakdoor.com/thailand-and-asi...hi-deaths.html (Norway proffs go to work on PhiPhi deaths riddle)

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Norway's Professors Pursue Phi Phi Killer Riddle

By Alan Morison and Chutima Sidasathian
Wednesday, October 7, 2009
Laleena Phi Phi Photo Album Above

Norway's Professors Pursue Phi Phi Killer Riddle - Phuket Wan

THE BEST forensic scientists in Norway are now trying to solve the year's most mystifying puzzle: what caused the sudden deaths of two young women tourists who occupied adjoining rooms in a guesthouse on Phi Phi, a tropical island paradise.

Two Scandinavian professors are attempting to put the pieces in place to resolve a mystery half a world away, a riddle that has so far eluded the best scientific endeavors Thailand can muster.



It's unusual to have scientists from one country become so deeply involved in a police case in another country. But then, the Phi Phi deaths are, as far as Phuketwan is able to tell, unique.

How did they die? Why did they die? These are questions that so far have no answers.

Norway is a relatively large country with a small-population, a nation that takes precious pride in maintaining a sense of community.

Life is treasured. Such is the level of concern about what took place involving Julie Bergheim at the Laleena Guesthouse on Phi Phi back in May that Norway decided on a diplomatically unconventional response.

With one or two possible exceptions, everybody wants the case solved. Norwegian Julie Bergheim, 22, and an American, Jill St Onge, 27, were young women in the prime of their lives before that strange weekend in paradise.

The family of the American woman is just as keen to have the case solved as Julie Bergheim's family. After all, Jill St Onge was on what amounted to a pre-nuptials honeymoon with her husband to be, Ryan Kells, when they both fell ill at Laleena.

The difference is a vital one. The Norwegian scientists have a body. The Americans do not.

In the aftermath of the two sudden deaths on Phi Phi, the bodies of both women were taken to Bangkok, and subjected to autopsies. Jill St Onge was cremated soon after at a Buddhist temple. Julie Bergheim was transported home.

Phuketwan has been led to believe that officials at the Norwegian embassy in Bangkok, where the ambassador and staff never give journalists any information, actually played a key role in orchestrating the second autopsy.

THE EMAIL was short and to the point: ''You are correctly informed that I, together with a colleague professor of forensic medicine, have been given the task to perform a second autopsy on the deceased in question, which has been done. The case is not yet concluded, but even when it is, we shall not be allowed to disclose the results to anybody else than Norwegian Police.

''Sincerely yours
Kari Ormstad,
professor of forensic medicine, MD, PhD''

And that was that. Our follow-up email, requesting the name of the other professor and the date of the second autopsy, brought no response.

Public Prosecutor Sjak Haaheim was a little more forthcoming when we telephoned. He knows that the practice of starting a second inquiry into a police case in another country is highly unusual.

As the leading prosecutor in Julie Bergheim's home county, it was his approval that was required for a second investigation, more properly called a ''survey,'' to commence.

Did it come because of the large groundswell of interest in solving a case involving a young Norwegian traveller, that national sense of community? Probably.

''My decision,'' Mr Haaheim tells us, ''was strongly motivated by the wishes of the family.

''We are not in any way putting a case for doubt on the Thai autopsy. It is just a second opinion. I decided there was a need to open a 'survey' case.''

The two forensic science professors performed the autopsy in June and have been working towards a set of findings ever since. The findings, says Mr Haaheim, will be presented to the family first, then made public.

Results may be sent back to the Thai authorities ''through diplomatic channels.'' At this stage, exactly what the reaction might be among the Thai investigators can only be the subject of speculation.

Of the four people who fell ill that weekend at Laleena Guesthouse, two are dead. Ryan Kells has told his version of events in an online blog.

He maintains that he noticed a chemical smell when he and Miss St Onge checked in that Saturday. He believes a gas made them both sick, and killed Miss Onge.

The other person with first-hand experience of what happened is Miss Bergheim's 19-year-old friend, another Norwegian, who also fell ill and only recovered after treatment in intensive care.

She has never given a public account of what happened. Mr Haaheim says he considered interviewing the woman, but it was decided that her privacy and her wishes should be respected.

What the 'survey' team has that the Thai investigators did not have is access to Norwegian medical records and, Mr Haaheim says, ''other information.''

SO THERE are three pockets of concern, spread across the globe, as the investigation remains at a standstill in Thailand and the 'survey' continues in Norway.

From the western seaboard of America, the Onge family has made it known online that they were not happy with the Thai autopsy report, which consisted of just three pages when they were expecting about 20. The material had to be translated into English first at the US Embassy in Bangkok, another time-consuming element in the process.

Some of the documents are confusing. This is especially the case with results of an ''environmental quality test'' made on June 13, six weeks after the deaths, that showed the presence of several gases in samples taken from Room 6 at Laleena Guesthouse at 1.35pm, but nothing in a slightly different test at 1.43pm.

The owner of the guesthouse, Rat Chuped, still maintains that there was nothing in her establishment capable of causing death.

She has no explanation for the illness that struck four healthy young people in adjoining Rooms 4 and 5 that May weekend.

Tourists are back now, staying in those same rooms, as if nothing unusual ever happened. Phi Phi is about an hour by ferry from Phuket, and the number of visitors is beginning to rise now for the holiday high season.

Phuketwan Latest Phuket News


<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<




Thanks Phuket Wan for staying on this.