Thread: Indonesian zoo accused of 'starving' sun bears by activists

Indonesian activists are lobbying for a zoo accused of starving its animals, including sun bears, to be shut down.

Recent videos taken at the Bandung Zoo by the activists show the bears looking skeletal and begging for food.

It is the latest accusation against the controversial attraction - it was previously criticised for mistreating an elephant which later died.

But a zoo official has denied the claims, saying that the bears are sufficiently fed and are healthy.

Indonesia's zoos are notorious for their inadequate conditions, with most scoring poorly against government-set standards.

The push to close down the Bandung Zoo is led by Scorpion Wildlife Trade Monitoring Group, which has been monitoring the sun bears since last year.

It has staged protests calling for the zoo's closure, and is also running an online petition.

Their videos, taken since mid-2016, show the bears pacing around in a concrete enclosure and standing up on their legs apparently begging visitors for food, who throw them junk food.

One clip also shows a bear defecating and immediately eating its own faeces.
"The enclosure is dirty, the water is polluted and unclean, and the floor has no grass. There are no live trees in the enclosure," Scorpion's programme director Gunung Gea told the BBC.

He said that activists had been periodically visiting the bears to feed them fruit, which is part of their natural diet.

'Soul-destroying'

"The fact that you can see their ribs, that is certainly not normal. They are underfed," said Gabriella Fredriksson from the International Union for Conservation of Nature.

Ms Fredriksson, who is co-chair of the sun bear expert committee, told the BBC that a sun bear eating faeces may be exhibiting "extreme boredom".

"Sun bears are very active animals. If they are stuck in a concrete pit with nothing to do, no stimulation for climbing and digging, it's soul destroying to say the least," she said.

The concrete floors would also damage their soft feet, while the lack of shade may cause cataracts in sun bears which are used to living in dimmer environments.

Mr Gea said that the other animals in the zoo also appeared to be in poor condition. Other videos taken by the group show deer with skin conditions, and chained-up elephants.

Reviews on travel rating website Tripadvisor of the zoo have been universally critical, with many saying the animals appeared neglected and in distress.

"A horrible place, hell on Earth for all these poor animals. Rusty cages, dirty place and really neglected animals," wrote one reviewer.

'Old case'

But Bandung Zoo spokesman Sudaryo dismissed the issue as an "old case". He told BBC Indonesian that they feed the bears regularly and also conduct regular health checks.

"We provide enough food... People say they are thin, but does (that) mean they are not healthy and they are not eating? It's not," he said.

He added that the bears were begging "because there are people who throw food at them", and that the zoo has told visitors to stop this practice.

The zoo last made the news in May 2016 after activists highlighted the plight of Yani, an elephant that died from an unknown disease. The zoo was said to have failed to give adequate medical care.

Bandung's mayor, Ridwan Kamil, told reporters last year that he had no power to shut down the zoo as it was privately run.

A Jakarta Globe report in 2015 said that out of the 58 registered zoos in Indonesia, only four were found to be "decent and appropriate".

The controversy over Bandung Zoo follows that of the zoo in Surabaya, dubbed by some the "zoo of death" after several animal deaths in recent years.

Indonesian zoo accused of 'starving' sun bears by activists - BBC News

Originally Posted by misskit

"The enclosure is dirty, the water is polluted and unclean, and the floor has no grass. There are no live trees in the enclosure,"

Quite common here, unfortunately. Very low admission fees (around $1 or less) and little funding means they have little hope of changing that anytime soon.

Originally Posted by misskit

and that the zoo has told visitors to stop this practice.

But done nothing more to follow that up...

The same sense of scruffy abandonment permeates much of Bandung as I recall.

Once in Indonesia, I was taken to a zoo by a local. Inside the zoo was a lone orangutan, sitting in a concrete room the size of a closet, with nothing to pass the time. I felt so sorry for that animal and told the guide so. He replied he thought the animals in the zoo were better off than many Indonesian people, who didn't have a dry place to live or food.

Better to leave the animals where they were than to make their lives hell in captivity.

Originally Posted by cyrille

The same sense of scruffy abandonment permeates much of Bandung as I recall.

It is the sense of scruffy abandonment that I liked about Sumatra. Why it has a place in my heart.

Originally Posted by misskit

Once in Indonesia, I was taken to a zoo by a local. Inside the zoo was a lone orangutan, sitting in a concrete room the size of a closet, with nothing to pass the time. I felt so sorry for that animal and told the guide so. He replied he thought the animals in the zoo were better off than many Indonesian people, who didn't have a dry place to live or food.

Better to leave the animals where they were than to make their lives hell in captivity.

Yep. A visit to most zoos isn't a particularly enjoyable experience for anyone with a sense of empathy. Especially in Asia.

A lot of zoos in SEA are poorly maintained and animals are treated poorly.

Bandung Zoo spokesman Sudaryo dismissed the issue as an "old case". He told BBC Indonesian that they feed the bears regularly and also conduct regular health checks.

"We provide enough food... People say they are thin, but does (that) mean they are not healthy and they are not eating? It's not," he said.

He added that the bears were begging "because there are people who throw food at them", and that the zoo has told visitors to stop this practice.

If they manage to get them released, I'd love to see him spend a year or so in their enclosure and then offer his comments on the diet.

I'd also like to force him to eat his own shit. (And no, I'm not German).