They DID hold territory. They claimed to be a STATE. That was a major part of their attraction. Now they have NO TERRITORY they cannot claim to be a Caliphate and cannot claim to be A STATE! 8 million people have been liberated and IS no longer have their own country to hide in. Got it? Fuck the mindset, what matters right now is they've lost all their land and thousands of their fighters have been killed. No matter that they still have support this is a major victory.